(Looks like I should have cleaned my toaster before taking the pic!)
I just wanted to quickly post an idea I saw a few weeks ago. I think it was on Pinterest, but I could be wrong. Turn your toaster into a mini toaster oven by placing it on its side. How easy was that to think of doing, yet it would have never occurred to me to try it.
This allows you to toast something other than dry bread. Just make sure it's not too thick or that the cheese or other topping doesn't melt over the edges. Voila!